Home Sweet Home: How to Choose the Right Homeowners Insurance

Choosing homeowners insurance is not complicated, but getting it right requires more than picking the lowest premium. Here is what actually matters when you are buying or reviewing a policy.

Start with Replacement Cost, Not Market Value

The most common mistake homeowners make is insuring their home for its market value rather than its replacement cost. These numbers are not the same. Market value includes the land and reflects local real estate conditions. Replacement cost is what it would actually cost to rebuild the structure from the ground up.

In the DC, Maryland, and Virginia area, construction costs are among the highest in the country. Labor and materials in the DMV run significantly above national averages. A home that sells for $600,000 in Silver Spring might cost $700,000 to rebuild, depending on finishes, square footage, and when you are rebuilding. Insuring to market value can leave you severely underinsured after a total loss.

Ask your agent to run a replacement cost estimate, not just use market value as the number.

Understand Your Coverage Types

Dwelling (Coverage A): The structure of your home. This is the number that needs to reflect actual replacement cost.

Other Structures (Coverage B): Detached garages, fences, sheds. Typically 10% of your dwelling limit by default, but that may not be enough for a large detached garage or pool house.

Personal Property (Coverage C): Your belongings. Standard policies cover personal property at actual cash value, meaning depreciation is applied. Replacement cost coverage for contents costs a bit more but pays what it actually costs to replace items, not what they were worth at the time of loss.

Loss of Use (Coverage D): Pays for hotel and living expenses if you cannot live in your home after a covered loss. In the DMV, where temporary housing costs are high, make sure this limit is adequate.

Liability (Coverage E): Covers you if someone is injured on your property or if you accidentally damage someone else’s property. Standard limits are $100,000 to $300,000, but an umbrella policy can extend that significantly at low cost.

What Standard Policies Do Not Cover

Flood damage is not covered by a standard homeowners policy. If you are in a FEMA flood zone in Maryland or Virginia, flood insurance is likely required by your mortgage lender. But even homes outside designated flood zones flood. More than 20% of flood claims come from low-to-moderate risk areas.

Earthquake coverage is also typically excluded. While not common in the DMV, the 2011 Virginia earthquake was a reminder that it is not impossible. A separate endorsement can add this for relatively little cost.

Sewer backup is another common gap. Water coming up through your drains is not covered by standard policies. An endorsement is inexpensive and worth adding.

Bundling and Discounts

Bundling homeowners with auto insurance typically saves 10 to 20% on both policies. Carriers like Erie, Travelers, Progressive, and Safeco all offer multi-policy discounts. Other common discounts include monitored alarm systems, new roofs, claims-free history, and loyalty credits.

Concrete Next Steps

If you are buying a new policy or reviewing your current one, do these three things:

First, confirm your dwelling limit is based on a replacement cost estimate, not purchase price or market value.

Second, check whether your personal property is covered at replacement cost or actual cash value, and upgrade if it is not.

Third, ask about flood and sewer backup coverage, especially if you are in Maryland or Northern Virginia where basement flooding is common.

Our agents work with homeowners across DC, Maryland, and Virginia and can do this review with you in about 20 minutes. Reach out if you want a second set of eyes on your coverage.