Excluded Drivers in Maryland: What Happens to Uninsured Motorist and PIP Coverage
Key takeaways
- Maryland lets you exclude a named driver from your auto policy, usually to avoid a cancellation, nonrenewal or surcharge caused by that driver’s record.
- If an excluded driver takes the car anyway, the policy generally pays nothing for damage they cause, to other people or to your own car.
- Maryland law also lets insurers deny uninsured motorist and PIP coverage to you and your household when an excluded driver is behind the wheel.
- An exclusion only works if the excluded person truly never drives the car. If that is not realistic, other options are usually safer.
Excluding a driver can keep a Maryland auto policy affordable, or keep it from being cancelled, when someone in the household has a poor driving record. But the exclusion is broader than most families expect. It does not just remove that person from the liability coverage. It can also remove the uninsured motorist and personal injury protection coverage that would otherwise protect everyone else in the car.
What Is an Excluded Driver in Maryland?
Under Maryland Insurance Article §27-609, if an insurer could cancel, refuse to renew or surcharge a private passenger auto policy because of one driver’s record or claims, it must offer to exclude that named driver instead. Once the driver is excluded, the premium may not reflect their record. Insurers use this most often for a household member with serious violations, an at-fault accident history, or a suspended license.
What Happens If an Excluded Driver Drives Your Car?
In plain terms, the Maryland Insurance Administration warns that there will be no coverage of any kind under your policy for damage an excluded driver causes, whether to other people or to your own car. That leaves the owner of the car and the driver personally exposed for injuries and property damage, which can easily run into six figures.
Excluded Drivers and Uninsured Motorist Coverage
This is the part most people miss. Maryland Insurance Article §19-509(f)(2) allows an insurer to exclude uninsured motorist (UM) coverage for the named insured, family members in the household, and anyone with their own auto insurance when they are hurt in or by the insured car while an excluded driver is operating it. The same exclusion carries over to Maryland’s enhanced underinsured motorist coverage under §19-509.1.
So if your excluded teenager borrows the car and is hit by an uninsured driver, the UM coverage you pay for may not protect you or your family members riding along. In Maryland Automobile Insurance Fund v. Baxter (2009), Maryland’s intermediate appellate court held that a pedestrian struck by an excluded driver was not covered under the policy’s UM coverage either.
What About Personal Injury Protection (PIP)?
Maryland requires at least $2,500 of PIP on every policy unless it is waived. Under §19-505, the excluded driver is carved out of PIP. Passengers and pedestrians are generally still covered, but the person you excluded is not.
Maryland Minimum Coverage, for Reference
- Liability: $30,000 per person, $60,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $15,000 for property damage.
- Uninsured motorist: at least the same minimums, and equal to your liability limits unless you waive the higher amount in writing.
- PIP: $2,500 unless waived.
- Enhanced underinsured motorist: the default on new policies issued on or after July 1, 2024 unless the first named insured signs a written waiver.
When Excluding a Driver Makes Sense, and When It Does Not
An exclusion works when the excluded person truly will not drive the car, for example a household member with a suspended license who has no access to the keys. It works poorly for a teen or young adult who lives at home and will be tempted to borrow a car in an emergency. In that situation, the safer options are usually to keep the driver on the policy with a higher deductible, assign them to the lowest-value car, take a defensive driving course where a carrier offers a discount, or move them to their own policy.
Because an exclusion can leave a household without the UM coverage it is paying for, we recommend reviewing it with an advisor before you sign. Capitol Benefits works with families in Gaithersburg, Rockville and across Maryland, DC and Northern Virginia to compare options from multiple carriers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you exclude a driver from car insurance in Maryland?
Yes. Under Maryland Insurance Article 27-609, if an insurer could cancel, nonrenew or surcharge your policy because of one driver’s record, it must offer to exclude that named driver instead.
Is an excluded driver covered by uninsured motorist coverage in Maryland?
Generally no. Maryland law allows insurers to exclude UM coverage for the named insured, household family members, and people with their own auto insurance when they are hurt in or by the car while an excluded driver is operating it.
What happens if an excluded driver crashes my car in Maryland?
Your policy will generally not pay for damage the excluded driver causes, to other people or to your own car, leaving you and the driver personally responsible.
Are there alternatives to excluding a driver?
Often. Keeping the driver on the policy with a higher deductible, assigning them to an older car, or moving them to their own policy can cost more up front but avoids the coverage gap an exclusion creates.
Related reading from Capitol Benefits
Ready when you are
Let's take a look at what you've got.
A real review of your current coverage. No deck, no pressure, and usually some money saved along the way.
